Skip to content
WITHNAIL & I · MEMBERSHIP PROSPECTUS · MMXXV

Chapter I · The Curators’ Club

A private, vetted network for people who buy with their eyes open.

Founded in Cecil Court in 1998 by Margaret Holroyd and David Pryce, Withnail & I has spent twenty-seven years building Britain’s most considered private dealing house. Membership is capped, selective, and quietly full — there are presently 4,820 paying members across 41 countries, and a waiting list we do not advertise.

Join The Curators’ Club Visit the Showroom

Annual membership from £180 · Single, Household and Trade tiers · First refusal on 12,000+ vetted pieces each year.

A corner of the Cecil Court showroom, photographed as a catalogue plate.
Plate I. The Cecil Court showroom, 09:14 on a Tuesday in November.

Chapter II · Three Doors, Same House

Three doors into the same vetted network — sized to the way you buy.

Membership is annual, renewed at the same rate, and reviewed each January. We do not run introductory discounts; the fee is the fee because the vetting is the vetting.

Tier I

Single

£180/ year

For the private collector buying for one household.

  • First-refusal alerts on every vetted lot, by post, email, or both.
  • Unlimited private viewings at Cecil Court, six days a week.
  • Four copies of the quarterly Holroyd-Pryce Index.
  • One named specialist as your first point of contact.
  • Entry to two members-only previews each year.
Apply for Single

Tier II · Most chosen

Household

£295/ year

For couples, families, and designers buying across one project or many.

  • Everything in Single, for two named members.
  • Reserved seats at four members-only previews.
  • Priority consignment review of items you wish to sell.
  • Annual on-site visit (UK mainland) by one of our specialists, by appointment.
  • Two guest passes per quarter for non-member viewings.
Apply for Household

Tier III

Trade

£420/ year

For dealers, interior designers, and institutional buyers.

  • Everything in Household, for up to four named users.
  • Direct line to our specialists in furniture, ceramics, silver, tribal, militaria, and 20th-century design.
  • Consignment submissions pre-screened within five working days.
  • Listing credit in the quarterly Index, by request.
  • One advisory hour per quarter with a Fellow of the RHS or our LAPADA-accredited specialist.
Apply for Trade

All tiers include VAT where applicable. Membership renews automatically at the prevailing rate; you may pause or cancel at any time before the renewal date in writing. We do not refund part-year memberships.

Chapter III · The First-Refusal Mechanic

What the £180 actually buys: the inventory the public never sees.

Every year, 31,500 items are offered to Withnail & I through our consignment pipeline of 230+ UK estate executors, probate solicitors, and private vendors. Of those, our fourteen specialists accept 38% — roughly 12,000 pieces — after the 47-point provenance and condition review. The remaining 62% is returned, with a note explaining why.

Members see the accepted 12,000 first. Each piece is described, measured, condition-graded, and priced before it is published to the open market. Members may reserve by post, telephone, or in person, with a 48-hour window of first refusal before a lot is released to the public catalogue.

This is the mechanic. It is why the fee exists, and it is why the average member has been with us for 6.4 years.

A condition report and loupe on the specialists' desk.
Plate II. A condition report, in progress, on a Tuesday afternoon.

Chapter IV · The Forty-Seven-Point Review

The craft of the house, in five chapters.

Every accepted lot passes through five sequential stages and forty-seven individual checks before it reaches a member. We do not abbreviate the process for speed, and we do not publish a piece that has not been physically inspected by one of our specialists.

  1. No. 01

    Consignment intake

    A piece arrives from one of our 230+ UK estate executors, probate solicitors, or private vendors. Twelve points are logged at intake: provenance narrative, vendor declaration, photographic record, prior sale history, vendor relationship, indemnity terms, export status, CITES status (where relevant), condition on arrival, declared value, declared age, and any prior restoration.

    Stage gate · 12 of 47 points

  2. No. 02

    Specialist attribution

    The piece is assigned to one of our fourteen in-house specialists — furniture, ceramics, silver, tribal, militaria, or 20th-century design. Attribution adds fourteen further points: maker, period, regional school, comparison examples, our internal comparable database, prior literature, marks, signatures, construction technique, joinery, materials analysis, patina assessment, repair history, and our confidence rating.

    Stage gate · 26 of 47 points

  3. No. 03

    Physical inspection

    The piece is unpacked, photographed under our standard lighting rig, and condition-graded by hand. Eleven points: structural integrity, surface condition, veneer or glaze state, joint soundness, drawer and door function, metalwork patina, textile condition (where present), upholstery state, pest or mould evidence, prior over-painting, and any cleaning required before sale.

    Stage gate · 37 of 47 points

  4. No. 04

    Pricing & catalogue copy

    A price is set against three comparables — our internal records, the most recent Holroyd-Pryce Index, and the open market. Six points: reserve price, public price, member-only price, commission structure, catalogue description in the house voice, and the condition disclaimer for the listing.

    Stage gate · 43 of 47 points

  5. No. 05

    Dispatch to members

    The lot is released to members with a 48-hour first-refusal window. Four final points: member alert issued, reservation logged, payment terms confirmed, and dispatch or collection arranged. Of 31,500 items offered in 2024, 11,970 reached this gate.

    Stage gate · 47 of 47 points

If your piece survives all forty-seven points, it earns a place in front of 4,820 members. If it does not, we tell you why, in writing, on the same day.

See Current Inventory

Chapter V · The Network, in Four Numbers

The scale, and the loyalty, of the house.

4,820

Paying members across 41 countries, including curators at the V&A, the Met, and the Rijksmuseum.

71%

Year-on-year renewal rate. Average member tenure: 6.4 years.

94%

Of members surveyed in 2024 would recommend the Club to a fellow collector.

38%

Of 31,500 items offered in 2024 cleared the 47-point review. The rest were returned, with a note.

Trade Publication of the Year, Antiques Trade Gazette Awards — 2018, 2021, 2023. Forty-seven appearances on BBC Radio 4’s Loose Ends, 2009–2024. Cited in House & Garden, Country Life, and the Financial Times.

Chapter VI · Practical Questions

The things a serious collector asks before paying £180.

Do I have to renew every year at the same rate?
Yes. Membership runs 1 January to 31 December and renews automatically at the prevailing rate. You may pause or cancel in writing at any time before the renewal date; part-year memberships are not refunded. The 71% renewal rate suggests most members do not exercise the option.
I live outside the UK. Is the Club still useful to me?
Members in 41 countries make active use of the network. First-refusal alerts are issued by email and post; condition reports and high-resolution photography are standard on every lot; and we arrange insured international shipping through two long-standing freight partners. We have members from Reykjavík to Auckland who have never set foot in Cecil Court.
Is this a substitute for a formal valuation by a RICS-qualified surveyor?
No. The Holroyd-Pryce Index and our catalogue prices are research and trading references, not formal valuations. For probate, insurance, or capital-events purposes you will still need a RICS-qualified surveyor; we are happy to recommend one from a short list we maintain, but we do not act as one ourselves.
I am an estate executor with a house to clear. How does consignment work?
We receive consignment submissions from 230+ UK estate executors and probate solicitors each year. Submit a list, photographs, and any provenance documentation by post or email to our consignments desk; a specialist will respond within five working days (Trade members) or ten working days (Single and Household members). Accepted lots are collected by our logistics partner at no charge inside the M25; outside the M25 collection is charged at cost.
What does “first refusal” actually mean in practice?
When a lot clears the 47-point review, members are alerted before the piece appears in the public catalogue. Members may reserve by telephone, email, or in person; the reservation is held for 48 hours. If two members reserve simultaneously, the lot is offered to the member with the longer tenure. After 48 hours, the lot is released to the public catalogue.
Are the specialists Fellows of anything, or members of any trade body?
Two of our fourteen specialists are Fellows of the Royal Horticultural Society; one is an accredited member of LAPADA. The remaining eleven hold a mixture of dealer accreditations, museum-adjacent curatorial roles, and forty-odd years of collective bench experience. Their biographies are published in full in the back of every quarterly Index.

If a question of yours is not answered here, write to us. We reply, by hand, within two working days.

Join The Curators’ Club Plan a Visit